How to make offers sellers can’t ignore

Last week, I pulled into a gas station on Tryon to top off the tank. Two pumps over, I overheard a guy telling his buddy, “Man, I should’ve sold that rental back in ‘21. Now I’m just hoping rates come down.”

He wasn’t angry, just stuck. No plan, no criteria, just vibes.

Then it hit me, real estate doesn’t punish bad markets as much as it punishes indecision. Deals go sideways when we wing it.

That’s why this week’s Playbook is all about giving sellers two offers they can’t ignore, and the Exit Strategy is about knowing exactly when you’ll hold, refi, or sell before you even sign the contract.

Charlotte’s market is too fast for gas station regrets. Let’s make decisions on purpose.

THE PLAYBOOK

The Double Offer Play

Goal: Boost acceptance odds and drop your all-in cost by giving sellers a clear, side-by-side choice.

Why it works

• Choice > Yes/No: Sellers pick between A or B (not Accept/Reject).

• Anchoring: A makes B feel reasonable.

• Certainty premium: Many sellers trade price for speed/clarity.

When to use

• Stale listings (15–45 DOM), tired landlords, estate sales.

• Dated homes/light–mid rehab.

• Motivated but not desperate sellers.

How to set it up (NC-friendly)

• Run comps → set your MAO (Max Allowable Offer).

• Draft two fully executable offers, each good for 24–48 hrs.

• Use NC’s Due Diligence Fee + Earnest Money to signal certainty.

• Include a one-page Offer Summary comparing key terms.

Offer A — Easy Choice (Anchor)

• Price: At or slightly above ask.

• Contingencies: Standard (inspection/appraisal/financing).

• DD Period: 10–14 days.

• DD Fee/EMD: Moderate.

• Close: Seller’s preferred date; flexible rent-back optional.

• Credits: None.

• Message: Highest headline price, conventional timeline.

Offer B — As-Is, Fast, Certain (Your Win)

• Price: Below A (at/under your MAO).

• Contingencies: As-is, inspection for info only; tight appraisal language (small gap coverage if financed).

• DD Period: Short (5–7 days).

• DD Fee/EMD: Higher, part/all hard after DD.

• Close: Fast (10–21 days) or exact date seller wants.

• Credits: Small closing credit only if needed.

• Message: Lower price, but clean, quick, and no repairs.

Package & deliver

• Email subject: “Two clean options for [Address] — choose your fit”

• Body: 5-line summary + PDF/one-pager table (Price, DD $, EMD, DD days, Close date, Credits, Repairs).

• Attach proof of funds/pre-approval and closing attorney info.

Mini example (keep math simple)

• List: $320k, your MAO: $306k

  • A: $322k, standard contingencies, 12-day DD.

  • B: $304k, as-is, 7-day DD, DD fee meaningfully higher, 14-day close.

• Many sellers pick B for certainty/speed → you land ≤ MAO.

Agent script (copy+paste)

• “We’ve sent two fully executable offers so your seller can choose the path that fits: A = highest headline price, standard process; B = quicker, as-is, fewer unknowns. Both expire tomorrow at 5 pm to keep everyone focused.”

Risk checks

• Don’t send during a formal “highest & best” unless invited.

• Make sure both offers stand alone (no “pick B or A void” language).

• Keep B attractive even with the lower price (tight timeline + strong DD/EMD).

Pro tips

• Emphasize smooth close with a local lender/attorney familiar with local deals.

• Offer a short post-occupancy on A to sweeten without upping credits.

DEALS OF THE WEEK

📍 2421 Toddville Rd, Charlotte, NC 28214
Listed at $630,000 | 2,424 sqft | 6 Bed, 4 Bath

Why It’s a great deal:

• Turnkey Rental: Tenant in place, fully upgraded, no immediate management hassles, start earning rental income immediately.

• Location & Flexibility: No HOA or rental restrictions; excellent proximity to high-demand areas (airport, recreation, commute), allowing short- or mid-term rentals for higher yields.

• High-Value Property: 6 bedrooms in like-new condition with high-end finishes, meaning strong appreciation potential and attractive rental income compared to comparable new builds.

Best Play

1. Short-Term Hold/Hard Money Strategy: Hold 6–12 months, rent cash flow may be slightly negative, refinance to a lower-rate conventional loan to stabilize cash flow.

2. Long-Term Rental: Keep tenant in place; refinance after 12–18 months into a conventional mortgage to turn it into a positive cash-flowing asset.

3. Sell After Appreciation/ARV: Minimal repairs needed; likely to sell near $650–675k after stabilization → modest profit if flipping is an option.

📍 14727 Choate Cir, Charlotte, NC 28273
Listed at $825,000 | 3,400 sqft | 8 Bed, 6 Bath

Why It’s a great deal:

• House Hack/Dual Income Potential: Live in one unit and rent the other to offset mortgage, or rent both for full income—immediate cash flow with minimal vacancy risk.

• New Construction + Large Units: Modern build (2023) with 4 bedrooms per unit and large 2-car garages, reducing maintenance risk and attracting higher-quality tenants.

• Flexible Investment: No HOA, no rental restrictions, large lot for potential upgrades, or use as short-term rental for higher returns.

Best Play

1. House Hack: Live in one unit, rent the other, offset mortgage while maintaining appreciation exposure.

2. Dual Rental Income: Continue renting both units to maximize monthly cash flow.

3. Short-Term Rental/Airbnb: Prime location near Lake Wylie, Carowinds, and Steele Creek; could generate higher returns if zoning and management allow.

📍 2404 Sides Rd, Rockwell, NC 28138
Listed at $499,000 | 2,490 sqft | 4 Bed, 4 Bath

Why It’s a great deal:

• Dual income potential: Each side of the duplex can rent separately, doubling rental income opportunities.

• Additional revenue streams: Detached shop and carports offer options for storage rental, workshop space, or future short-term income.

• Turnkey updates on one side: Right side already has new flooring and carpet, reducing immediate repair costs and rental downtime.

Best Play

• Rehab & Hold: Update minor cosmetic items, leverage duplex income + shop for long-term cash flow.

• BRRRR Strategy (Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat): Hard money loan allows fast acquisition, then refinance to conventional mortgage to lower interest and free up capital.

THE EXIT STRATEGY

Set Your Exit Criteria Before You Buy

Goal: Lock in a pre-purchase plan so you’re never guessing when to sell, refi, or hold.

Why it works

• Eliminates gut feel panic selling.

• Forces disciplined decision-making.

• Protects your returns from emotional market swings.

When to set it

• Before you write the first offer.

• Works for flips, BRRRRs, long-term holds.

• Especially key in changing interest rate environments.

Core framework (3 buckets)

1. Yield Targets – Decide the minimum performance that justifies holding.

2. Market Conditions – Define the outside triggers that override your yield.

3. Time Horizon – Pre-set the max years you’ll own before reevaluating.

Step 1 — Set Your Yield Targets

• Flips: Net profit ≥ 15–20% of ARV after all costs.

• BRRRR/Refi: Min. cash-out at 75–80% LTV + DSCR ≥ 1.25.

• Rentals: Cash-on-cash ≥ 8–10% or IRR ≥ 15%.

• Charlotte Tip: Adjust targets for submarkets. Plaza Midwood rents grow faster than Concord, so IRR can be more aggressive.

Step 2 — Define Market Condition Triggers

• Interest rates: If rates drop ≥ 1% from purchase rate, refi review.

• Local prices: If median price in your zip jumps 15%+ in 12 months, consider selling into strength.

• Rental demand: Vacancy > 2 months → shift to exit mode.

• Charlotte Tip: Track MLS Months of Inventory → < 2 = seller’s market, > 5 = buyer’s market.

Step 3 — Fix Your Time Horizon

• Short-term: ≤ 12 months (flips/new builds).

• Medium-term: 3–5 years (BRRRR seasoning, mid-term rent plays).

• Long-term: 10+ years (legacy holds).

• Write it in your deal file → no “we’ll just see” creep.

Packaging your exit criteria (pre-purchase)

• One-page “Deal Profile” in your due diligence binder:

  • Property address & strategy.

  • Yield targets (profit %, cash-on-cash, DSCR).

  • Market triggers (price change %, rate drop %, vacancy tolerance).

  • Max hold period.

• Share with partner/lender so everyone’s on same page.

Example

• Duplex in NoDa at $480k.

  • Yield: Cash-on-cash ≥ 9%.

  • Market trigger: Sell if median NoDa price rises 18%+ in 24 months.

  • Hold: Max 5 years.

• Outcome: Year 3, rents plateau + prices spike 20% → sell, net $92k.

Agent/Lender talking point

• “We set our exit criteria upfront so we don’t chase the market. If X or Y happens, we’re already positioned to move.”

Pro tips (Charlotte)

• Watch rezoning and light rail expansion maps—they can shift exit timing up or down.

• Pair with a local tax pro → capital gains timing can matter more than price swings.

Until next week,

Know someone who would enjoy this newsletter? Please share this with them.

Was this email forwarded to you? Subscribe here

Quick links:

• Interested in sponsorship or advertising? Reach out

• House hunting or selling? Connect with an agent

• Need a contractor? Post a job